The show started with all the couples hanging out and Brandon “kicking it solo”. Trey and Laura’s awkward relationship continued to whither. Brandon commented on how pathetic Laura looks while she follows Trey around like a little puppy. Robb did a front flip into his bed and he kneed himself in the face and bloodied it. Robb then left a cute note in Marie’s bed and she became more smitten with him.
Marie and Latoya went into town to hang out and go shopping. Robb’s lip looked terrible the next morning. The whole house except Trey went out for the night. Trey used the alone time to call his girl Chelsea back home. She was very distant, but he did not do much to comfort her. He tried to say that he avoids Laura’s affection (for like 3 seconds) then he gives in.
Latoya decided to go Kayaking for the first time with Marie and it took them 45 minutes to get the boats in the water. The girls then struggled to get 20 feet off shore. The waves and wind got the girls in trouble and their boat chauffer Lee had to save them. Robb met a girl Emily 3 weeks before he left home and he called her. She told him that she was not interested in anyone else back home because he ruined other men for her. It was very dramatic as she said, “he broke her”. Once back on safe land Marie admitted to the girls that she had an adult crush on Robb.
Robb told Marie that Emily might be coming to St. Thomas. That just made Marie more confused about the situation. Marie called Trey out about his actions in the house. She did make a lot of sense when she told him that he could always go back to his girl back home. He tried to make Marie confirm that he could bring a different girl home every night if he wanted and it sounded very insecure. Robb later confirmed that his girl Emily was coming for sure.
The whole house went out to party and the drinks were flowing. Marie used the night out to show her disgust for Robb having a girl back home by ignoring him. Marie later showed that her and Robb are one of a kind when she busted her own lip just like Robb did the day before. That led to Robb and Marie having a fight. She called him a brat, which struck a nerve and both of them ended the night very upset at each other. Laura then spoke with Trey about him going so slow and about his girl back home. There might be some love potion #9 on that island because certain people have been hit with the infatuation bug this season and we are only 3 shows into it.
Marie brought Robb a coffee in the morning and they made up after he frankly told her that she was being a bitch the night before. The next day quickly turned into night and Marie gave Robb a very nice massage. The playful flirting continued from both ends. The crew bundled up in the rain to head to the clubs. Marie tried to hit on a local dude to make Robb jealous and he became very upset and called her out about it. Laura had a few drinks and guaranteed she was going to rock Trey’s bed later. The night vision camera finally had to do some work this season as the sheets were moving in Trey and Laura’s room. The next morning Laura complimented Trey’s size and said it did not match his height. Swift showed up for 5-10 words to tell Trey that things will definitely change. Robb continued to be very confused by the Marie situation and they decided to go out and party to help clarify it.
We got 30 seconds of partying and then Robb inexpiably left early. Marie admitted to Brandon that she liked Robb a lot. Robb went home early and called Emily. Emily then broke the news that she had sex with someone because she thought he was having sex with girls. Robb was very upset by this as he thought he had an angel waiting for him back home. Robb then smashed the phone receiver on his head a few times and broke it on his leg before he hung up on her. Marie came back to the house to find Robb stoically sitting outside. Brandon told Robb Marie’s true feelings, but he was in a cationic state at the time. Marie asked Robb why he left and she thought he went home with another girl.
The show ended with all the couples flirting again. LaToya then ate some chicken nuggets very suggestively in front of Swift. Marie lit up at the idea of cuddling with Robb. The night camera came out again, but Brandon’s snoring may have interrupted the intimacy of the couples. LaToya and Swift slept in the same bed, but it was strictly platonic. Robb and Marie woke up and talked about their first kiss the night before. Brandon was very creeped out by Laura grooming Trey. Marie admitted to the camera that Robb was everything she wanted in a guy and they were very much on the same page.